In 2004, Dr. Enrique Tomeu closed his obstetrics practice in Virginia Beach, VA and left town after being sued repeatedly for allegedly causing injury to babies during delivery. After leaving he went to New Zealand and practiced for a year. A New Zealand coroner found him partially responsible for a baby’s death prompting Tomeu to be relieved of his duties there. His departure calls into question how doctors accused of malpractice can just pick up stakes and keep practicing. Tomeu’s example illustrates that despite widespread tort reform and better access to a doctor’s malpractice history, it is still possible for them to stay a step ahead of their records by moving.
The New Zealand coroner found the death of Ella McMillan-Meager two days after her delivery by Tomeu was caused by “a massive subgaleal hemorrhage,” a bleeding on the brain that can result from the use of a vacuum device being applied to the baby’s head. During testimony witnesses said that Tomeu climbed onto the birthing bed to get better leverage to pull the baby from the birth canal during a difficult labor. The coroner further testified that a factor attributed to the death was blood loss that resulted when the umbilical cord became tangled around the baby’s head and while trying to untangle it the cord tore out of the infant’s body. The coroner expressed concern that Tomeu tried to “sanitize” the medical record by directing the hospital staff not to record the torn cord and to report he was able to deliver the baby in one gentle pull.
Tomeu has since returned to the U.S. and is practicing medicine in North Carolina. He is now on staff at clinic for women in Jacksonville and has privileges at a nearby hospital. A spokesman for the hospital said a state law mandating confidentiality of the credentialing process prevents the hospital from saying whether they are aware of Tomeu’s history. According to Virginia Beach Circuit Court records, Tomeu was named as a defendant in seven malpractice lawsuits over 10 years. Three of those cases resulted in payments to the plaintiffs, two settlements and one jury verdict totaling more than $500,000. The circumstances in those three cases were similar. Each time, a baby delivered by Tomeu allegedly suffered shoulder dystocia, an injury that can occur when the baby's shoulder becomes caught behind the mother's pelvic bone during delivery. In that position, the nerves that connect the baby's shoulder, arm and hand to the spinal cord can be stretched, torn or pulled out of the spinal column causing Erb’s Palsy,a form of paralysis that can leave the shoulder, arm and hand permanently disabled. The plaintiff’s lawyer in all three cases said Tomeu’s ability to continue practice medicine reflects a flawed system of regulating physicians.